Skip to content
ElectionsAnalysis

An Autopsy of the 2026 Midterm Election

What went wrong for Republicans in 2026.

· 26 min read · Edited by Connor McFarland

The 2026 Election Autopsy: How Republicans Lost the Next Generation, and How to Win It Back

By the High School Republican National Federation (HSREPS) · November 2026

Republicans lost both chambers of Congress on November 3, 2026, and young voters broke 73–25 for Democrats. This autopsy is the independent review HSREPS promised in its November 5 statement: an honest account of what worked, what did not, and how we move forward.

This autopsy answers four questions:

  1. The national picture. How large was the loss, and where did it happen?

  2. The electorate. What do the exit polls say about young voters, and about the issues that moved everyone else?

  3. The races. What happened in each major Senate, governor and House contest?

  4. Our own work. How did HSREPS organization, outreach and digital programs perform, and what did chapter leaders see on the ground?

The findings close with recommendations built on our two stated priorities: meeting students where they already are, on campus and online, and continuing to grow our chapters.

A note on sources: race results come from network projections as of November 4–5, and some races were still being counted at the time of writing. Exit poll figures come from the NBC News national exit poll (conducted by SSRS), which is a survey estimate, not a vote count.

The national picture

Democrats flipped at least seven Senate seats and took control of both chambers. Republicans entered the election with a 53–47 Senate majority; Democrats now hold at least 54 seats, with Alaska and Mississippi still uncalled (CBS News). CBS estimates Democrats will hold between 251 and 268 House seats once counting ends (CBS News).

The losses reached deep into Republican territory. Democrats won statewide in Texas for the first time in 32 years, took Senate seats in Kansas and South Carolina, and won the governorships of Texas, Georgia and Iowa (Northeastern). In South Carolina, Trump-won counties swung toward Democrats by about 21 points on average, per a New York Times analysis cited by Northeastern.

  • Texas: James Talarico (D) over Ken Paxton (R). Democratic flip.

  • South Carolina: Annie Andrews (D) over Darline Graham (R). Democratic flip.

  • Kansas: Adam Hamilton (D) over Sen. Roger Marshall (R). Democratic flip.

  • Maine: Troy Jackson (D) over Sen. Susan Collins (R). Democratic flip.

  • Iowa: Josh Turek (D) over Ashley Hinson (R). Democratic flip.

  • Ohio: Sherrod Brown (D) over Jon Husted (R). Democratic flip.

  • North Carolina: Roy Cooper (D) over Michael Whatley (R). Democratic flip.

  • Michigan: Abdul El-Sayed (D) over Mike Rogers (R). Democratic hold.

  • Georgia: Sen. Jon Ossoff (D) over Mike Collins (R). Democratic hold.

  • New Hampshire: Chris Pappas (D) over John Sununu (R). Democratic hold.

  • Mississippi: Scott Colom (D) vs. Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith (R). Not yet called; Colom led by dozens of votes.

  • Alaska: Mary Peltola (D) vs. Sen. Dan Sullivan (R). Not yet called.

The one competitive Republican hold was Nebraska, where Sen. Pete Ricketts beat independent Dan Osborn. Republicans also held open or incumbent seats in Florida, Louisiana, Montana, Alabama, Wyoming, Idaho, Tennessee, South Dakota and West Virginia.

What the exit polls say

Young voters backed Democrats 73–25, a 48-point margin. Two years ago that margin was 14 points. Republicans had the youth vote within reach in 2024, and in two years they gave it away.

Behind that collapse sit three causes the rest of the electorate shared: a referendum on President Trump, an unpopular war in Iran, and a Republican agenda written for Washington rather than for the voters paying the bills.

The youth vote

Voters aged 18–29 were 11% of the 2026 electorate, and they voted 73–25 Democratic for the House (NBC News exit poll). A separate survey by NORC puts the split at 66–31 (CIRCLE). By the exit poll's measure, it is the widest Democratic margin with young voters in at least five cycles.

  • The 2024 gains are gone. In 2024, 56% of young men voted for Trump (AP VoteCast). In 2026, 59% of young men voted for a Democrat for the House, and 70% of young women did (CIRCLE).

  • New voters started out Democratic. First-time midterm voters were 9% of the electorate and broke 65–33 for Democrats. Habits formed in a first election tend to last.

  • Young voters decided close races. In Mississippi, where the Senate race is separated by a few dozen votes, Democrat Scott Colom won 76% of voters under 30. In South Carolina, Annie Andrews won 66% of them; in Georgia, Jon Ossoff won 71% (CIRCLE).

[INSERT IMAGE: Youth_Vote_Chart.png]

In 2024, Republicans came closer with young voters than in any other year shown. Two years later, the Democratic margin was the widest of the five. Earlier years come from a different exit poll than 2026, so compare the trend rather than single points.

Trump was on the ballot

Six in ten voters said Donald Trump was a reason for their House vote: 44% to oppose him and only 16% to support him. Those voting against him went 97–2 Democratic.

  • Trump's job approval among voters was 37%, with 54% strongly disapproving.

  • 62% said Trump puts his own interests ahead of the country's.

  • 71% said Congress is not doing enough to check the presidency. Voters held the Republican Congress responsible for that.

Republicans won the 40% of voters for whom Trump was not a factor, 67–30. Where the election was about our candidates and not about him, we were competitive.

The war in Iran

63% of voters said the U.S. made the wrong decision in taking military action against Iran, and 74% called the war a crucial or major factor in their vote. Voters who called it crucial went 72–26 Democratic. Asked about America's role in the world, 43% wanted a less active role and only 28% a more active one.

Washington's agenda, not the voters'

Voters told us what they wanted: lower costs, a stable economy and an honest government. On the issues Republicans in Washington pushed, the public was against us.

  • Cost of living: 89% called it a crucial or major factor; 79% said inflation caused hardship. Crucial or major factor: 59–39 Democratic.

  • The economy: 75% rated it not so good or poor; 44% said they are worse off than two years ago. Worse off: 75–23 Democratic.

  • Prices: 63% blamed Trump's policies for higher prices. Those voters: 84–14 Democratic.

  • Tariffs: 66% said tariffs hurt the national economy; 64% said they hurt their area. Hurt the nation: 81–18 Democratic.

  • AI data centers: 76% oppose a new data center in their community; 57% expect AI to hurt society. Opposed: 64–34 Democratic.

  • Healthcare: 61% want a bigger federal role; 55% said Trump's policies made their costs worse. Costs worse: 83–15 Democratic.

  • Corruption: 55% called it crucial to their vote. Crucial: 63–35 Democratic.

The issues where Republicans still led were not the ones voters ranked first. Immigration was the top issue for 14% of voters and crime for 3%, against 39% for the economy and 33% for the state of democracy. Even on immigration, 58% said enforcement has gone too far and 60% disapproved of ICE.

We lost the middle

Independents voted 58–38 Democratic and self-described moderates 66–32. Only 40% of voters viewed the Republican Party favorably, against 47% for the Democratic Party. Voters who liked neither party, 15% of the electorate, chose Democrats 61–33.

Unless noted, figures are from the NBC News national exit poll conducted by SSRS (last updated November 4, 2026). Exit polls are survey estimates, not vote counts.

Race-by-race autopsies: Senate

The races below are chosen by money: the contests with the most spending in 2026, and where Republicans still lost by a wide margin. Spending covers candidates and outside groups, as reported to the FEC through November 5, 2026 (Dave Manuel money tracker).

Republicans did not win a single one of the ten most expensive Senate races of 2026; Alaska is still being counted.

  • Texas ($680M): Ken Paxton lost 43.0% to 55.1%.

  • Ohio ($505M): Sen. Jon Husted lost 45.2% to 50.0%.

  • Michigan ($434M): Mike Rogers lost by about 6 points.

  • Iowa ($255M): Ashley Hinson lost 46.4% to 50.5%.

  • Maine ($199M): Sen. Susan Collins lost by about 7 points.

  • Georgia ($184M): Mike Collins lost to Sen. Jon Ossoff.

  • Alaska ($150M): Sen. Dan Sullivan's race is not yet called.

  • South Carolina ($142M): Sen. Darline Graham lost 46.7% to 51.1%.

  • North Carolina ($139M): Michael Whatley lost 39.2% to 58.7%.

  • Kansas ($118M): Sen. Roger Marshall lost 44.8% to 53.0%.

Results are unofficial and some counts are incomplete; each race's source is cited in its autopsy below, and Georgia and Alaska in the national picture above.

Texas

Republicans lost both of Texas's top races, in the most expensive state of the 2026 cycle. Donald Trump carried Texas by about 14 points two years earlier.

Senate: Ken Paxton lost because Republicans picked the wrong candidate

Democrat James Talarico beat Attorney General Ken Paxton 55.1% to 43.0%, ending a 32-year Republican winning streak in Texas statewide races (Decision Desk HQ).

  • Result: Talarico 55.1%, Paxton 43.0%.

  • Candidate fundraising: Talarico $146 million, Paxton $22 million.

  • Total spending, all sources: $680 million.

The $680 million total makes it the most expensive Senate race on record. About half of the $573 million in ads came from PACs, not the candidates (KSAT, citing AdImpact and CNN).

The wrong nominee. Republicans held this seat with an incumbent, John Cornyn. Paxton beat him in a May 26 runoff, 63.8% to 36.2%, a week after Trump endorsed Paxton (Wikipedia). Paxton had been impeached by the Texas House in 2023 and acquitted by the Senate. During the runoff, Cornyn hammered Paxton's legal troubles and alleged corruption, and Paxton's wife filed for divorce on "biblical grounds."

Republicans nominated that candidate in an election about corruption. Corruption was crucial to 55% of voters nationally, and those voters broke 63–35 Democratic.

The nominee was chosen by 1.39 million runoff voters. Nearly 9.9 million Texans voted in November, so the runoff electorate was about 14% of the general one. A candidate built for a small, motivated primary was handed to the whole state, and the whole state said no.

The candidate we should have run: Wesley Hunt. HSREPS believes Rep. Wesley Hunt would have been the strongest Republican in this race. He is 44, a West Point graduate and former Army Apache pilot who served in Iraq, and has represented Texas's 38th District since 2023 (Wikipedia). He backed Trump in 2024 while building a record of his own, and he carried none of Paxton's legal baggage.

The early polling backs this up. An Emerson poll in January 2026 had Hunt leading Talarico 47–44, while Paxton only tied him at 46–46 (Emerson College Polling). A University of Houston and Texas Southern poll had Hunt ahead by 6 (RealClearPolling). No one can know whether Hunt would have won in a year like this one. But every matchup showed Paxton as the weakest Republican on the board.

Primary voters never gave Hunt that chance: he finished third with 13.5%. That is the real lesson. A nominating process that ignores general-election strength, and ignores what young voters want in a candidate, will keep producing nominees like Paxton.

Governor: Greg Abbott lost teachers and rural Texas

Democrat Gina Hinojosa unseated Gov. Greg Abbott 52.8% to 45.7% (MultiState). Abbott was a three-term incumbent who began 2026 with more than $100 million in his campaign account (Texas Tribune). He lost two constituencies Republicans had long counted on.

Teachers. Texas employs more than 400,000 public school teachers and staff. The president of Texas AFT, a teachers' union, estimates that 20–25% of its members are conservatives who vote Republican (Fort Worth Star-Telegram). Abbott gave them reasons to vote against him:

  • Vouchers. He championed the $1 billion private-school voucher program passed in 2025. Opponents called it money taken from public schools.

  • State takeovers. The state has run Houston's schools since 2023 and has intervened in Fort Worth and Lake Worth.

  • A state mandate for student clubs. In December 2025, Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick announced a plan to put a Turning Point USA "Club America" chapter in every Texas high school. Abbott said schools that blocked one should be reported to the Texas Education Agency for "meaningful disciplinary action" (Education Week). Turning Point does valuable work with young conservatives, and student-started Club America chapters are an asset to the movement. The mistake was the state ordering them onto every campus. Teachers, including the conservatives among them, heard the government taking sides in the classroom.

The backlash showed up on the ballot. Democrats with public-education backgrounds won up and down the ballot, and Republican state Rep. Marc LaHood, who backed vouchers, lost his seat to Zack Dunn (San Antonio Report). Turnout set records: 7.7 million Texans voted early, a 40.5% rate that beat the 2018 midterm record (Texas Tribune).

Data on teacher turnout specifically has not yet been published; voter-file analyses usually arrive weeks after an election.

Rural Texas and data centers. In 2025, Abbott vowed to make Texas the "epicenter of AI development." As rural communities filled with data centers, residents blamed him for noise, air quality and rising electric bills. He reversed course with a temporary pause on new projects, which rural voters called election-year pandering (Texas Tribune). Nationally, 76% of voters oppose a new data center in their own community.

Rural Republicans then stayed home. Since 2022, urban turnout rose nearly 8 points while rural turnout rose about 1.4. Talarico cut the Republican margin in rural Texas by about 10 points compared with 2018, and won nearly 41% in Lubbock County (Texas Tribune). Republican Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller blamed the voucher push and said, "Rural Texas didn't have anybody to vote for tonight."

What HSREPS takes from Texas

  1. Nominate for November, not for the runoff. The party had a younger, cleaner, stronger candidate in Wesley Hunt and nominated Ken Paxton instead.

  2. Student-led beats state-led. Conservative clubs that students start themselves strengthen the movement. Clubs announced from the Governor's Mansion with a threat of discipline hand our opponents an argument about government in the classroom. HSREPS chapters are started by students who want them. That model survives a backlash, and it is the one the party should fund.

  3. Listen to the communities we represent. Rural Texans told Republicans what they thought of vouchers and data centers long before November. The party heard Washington and donors instead.

Ohio: $505 million, and a Democrat ran as the populist

Sherrod Brown beat Sen. Jon Husted 50.0% to 45.2% in the special election for JD Vance's former seat (Poliwave, unofficial).

Cause of death: we gave away our own issues. Brown ran on affordability, workers, a ban on stock trading by members of Congress, and making data centers pay for their own electricity and water (Newsweek). Those are populist positions Republican voters agree with: 76% of voters nationally oppose a data center in their community, and corruption was crucial to 55%. Ohio Republicans let a Democrat own them.

Lesson: Republicans won Ohio by standing for working families against Washington. When we defend Washington instead, Ohio votes for the candidate who doesn't.

Michigan: the young men we won in 2024 walked away

Abdul El-Sayed beat Mike Rogers for the open seat, leading 52% to 46% when he declared victory (Fox 2 Detroit). Rogers had narrowly lost Michigan's Senate race in 2024.

Cause of death: broken promises to new voters. Bridge Michigan interviewed Ethan Harbin, 21, of Eaton County, who voted for Trump in his first election. In 2026 he voted for El-Sayed and other Democrats for the top offices, while still picking Republicans for local races like school board. He said he feels "burned" by Trump's unfulfilled promises (Bridge Michigan).

Harbin is the story of this election in one voter. He was ours, he still likes Republicans close to home, and he left us on the national ballot.

Lesson: A young voter won in one election is not a young voter kept. Keeping them takes year-round contact, which is exactly what HSREPS chapters do.

Iowa: Iowans split their tickets against Washington

Josh Turek beat Rep. Ashley Hinson 50.5% to 46.4% for the seat Joni Ernst left open (Newsweek).

Cause of death: tariffs and the war. Turek argued that tariffs hurt Iowa farmers and attacked Hinson's House votes on the Iran war. Republicans still won several other statewide races in Iowa. Iowa did not turn blue; Iowans voted against the federal agenda and kept Republicans they trusted at home.

Lesson: Farm-state voters will split their tickets when Washington's trade policy reaches their kitchen table. Our candidates need room to say so.

Maine: outspent our opponents and still lost

Troy Jackson ended Sen. Susan Collins's nearly 30-year career, leading by about 7 points when the race was called (Maine Public). Republican groups spent more than $130 million, against $94 million from Democratic groups. Jackson only entered the race in late July, after the Democrats' original nominee was replaced.

Cause of death: the national environment. Analysts cited Trump's unpopularity, the Iran war, and fuel prices in a state where many families heat with oil (Newsweek). The independent and split-ticket voters who carried Collins in the past did not turn out.

Lesson: Collins had the most independent brand in the party, a money advantage, and a late-starting opponent. When a seasoned incumbent loses with all three, the problem is not the candidate.

South Carolina: a famous name is not a candidate

Annie Andrews beat Sen. Darline Graham 51.1% to 46.7% with 99% counted (WMBF). Trump won South Carolina by 18 points in 2024.

Cause of death: candidate selection. After Sen. Lindsey Graham's sudden death in July, his sister Darline Graham was appointed to serve out his term, then won a condensed special primary for the full term. Trump encouraged her to run. Her prior post was commissioner of the South Carolina Commission for the Blind, and during the primary she said she was "not that informed on national security" (CBS News).

Lesson: Republicans had a deep bench in South Carolina and a short window to use it. The party chose a name over a candidate, in a state we should never lose.

North Carolina: the party's own man lost by 19 points

Former Gov. Roy Cooper beat Michael Whatley 58.7% to 39.2% for Thom Tillis's open seat (WRAL).

Cause of death: an insider nominee, then abandonment. Whatley had never run for office. He chaired the North Carolina GOP from 2019 to 2023, and Trump picked him to run the RNC through the 2024 election before endorsing him for this seat. The Senate Leadership Fund pledged $71 million in April, then canceled its North Carolina spending and moved the money to Kansas. Whatley entered October with about $916,000 against Cooper's $12.5 million, and suspended his TV ads.

Lesson: Party leadership picked the nominee and then left him without the money to compete. Party service is not the same as electability, and the party that chooses a candidate owes him a campaign.

Kansas: an incumbent who campaigned too late

Adam Hamilton, a Methodist pastor running as a centrist, beat Sen. Roger Marshall 53.0% to 44.8% with 93% counted (Newsweek). It is the first Democratic Senate win in Kansas in 94 years (OPB).

Cause of death: complacency. Marshall's ads did not start until late August, and Hamilton outraised him, especially among Kansans. Marshall took fire over a Florida vacation home and his collection of unpaid patient bills as a doctor. Rallies with Trump and Vice President Vance did not save him. Hamilton won moderate Republicans and independents frustrated with the cost of living and the Iran war.

Lesson: No seat is safe when voters are angry. An incumbent who starts campaigning in August is betting the seat on party loyalty, and in 2026 that bet lost.

What the Senate map tells us

  1. Candidate selection decided the worst losses. Texas, South Carolina and North Carolina were winnable seats lost by nominees chosen for loyalty, name or party service rather than strength in November.

  2. The national agenda sank the rest. In Ohio, Iowa, Maine and Kansas, voters named the same causes: prices, tariffs and the war in Iran.

  3. Money did not fix either problem. Republicans lost nine of the ten most expensive races, and the tenth, Alaska, is still being counted.

Race-by-race autopsies: governors

Democrats took at least five governorships from Republicans and now hold a majority of the nation's governors (Fox News). Even where Republicans held on, the margins were a warning: Florida by 1.3 points, Tennessee by 2.5, Alabama by 4.1 and South Carolina by 4.5.

  • Texas: Gov. Greg Abbott (R) lost to Gina Hinojosa (D), 45.7% to 52.8%.

  • Georgia: Rick Jackson (R) lost to Keisha Lance Bottoms (D), 45.7% to 54.3%.

  • Ohio: Vivek Ramaswamy (R) lost to Amy Acton (D), 44.4% to 52.3%.

  • Iowa: Zach Lahn (R) lost to Rob Sand (D), 44.5% to 55.5%.

  • Nevada: Gov. Joe Lombardo (R) lost to Aaron Ford (D), 44.3% to 51.5%.

Alaska and Kansas are still uncalled. Results are unofficial, per Fox News as of November 5. Texas is covered in the Senate section above.

Georgia: $200 million could not buy it

Keisha Lance Bottoms beat businessman Rick Jackson by about 8 points, becoming the nation's first Black woman governor. Jackson spent more than $200 million of his own fortune (Newsweek). As of late October he had raised about $124 million to Bottoms's $5.8 million (Wikipedia).

Cause of death: a nominee chosen by money, branded as a copy. Jackson entered the race in February with little political profile and spent a record $83 million in the primary alone. He called himself "just like Trump, but with a Southern tone," then beat the candidate Trump and Gov. Brian Kemp had endorsed, Lt. Gov. Burt Jones, in a bitter runoff. In the final weeks he talked less about Trump, while Bottoms promised to protect Georgians from the "chaos coming out of Washington."

Lesson: A candidate who runs as a copy of Washington cannot then run against it. Georgia voters wanted protection from the national agenda, and our nominee had built his whole campaign on it.

Ohio: Ohioans punished a cruel campaign

Amy Acton beat Vivek Ramaswamy 52.3% to 44.4%, ending 16 years of Republican governors in Ohio (Fox News).

Cause of death: the campaign's own conduct. In the final month, Ramaswamy aired an ad featuring Acton's estranged mother calling her daughter "a liar." The mother had lost custody of her children decades ago after her husband was indicted for raping Acton as a child. Five former Ohio governors joined a bipartisan backlash, and the campaign pulled the ad about a week before the election (OPB).

Acton, a physician and former state health director under Gov. Mike DeWine, ran on affordability and healthcare and painted Ramaswamy as a wealthy outsider. His own party was split: primary challenger Casey Putsch won nearly 18% and later said he would vote for Acton.

Lesson: Voters will forgive a lot, but not cruelty. In Kansas, Adam Hamilton called his own win a rebuke of "unkindness and cruelty" in Washington. Young voters notice how we treat people, and they decide what kind of party we are by it.

Iowa: a first-time candidate in an open seat

Rob Sand beat businessman Zach Lahn 55.5% to 44.5% for the seat Gov. Kim Reynolds left open. He is the first Democrat elected governor of Iowa since 2006 (Iowa Public Radio). Trump carried Iowa by more than 13 points two years earlier.

Cause of death: an untested nominee and the voucher fight. Lahn was a first-time candidate whom Trump endorsed after the primary. He defended the state's private-school tuition program, while Sand ran on public schools, water quality and government accountability. Sand raised a record $37.8 million; the Republican Governors Association gave Lahn $15.5 million (MultiState).

Lahn said he ran partly because young Iowans could not build lives in their own state. He asked the right question. But a campaign that starts asking it in an election year is too late to answer it.

Lesson: Vouchers were a liability in Texas and Iowa alike. And a candidate who says young people matter needs an organization that can reach them.

Nevada: a pragmatic incumbent sunk by the national tide

Attorney General Aaron Ford unseated Gov. Joe Lombardo 51.5% to 44.3% (Fox News). Lombardo was one of only two Republican governors to lose reelection, with Abbott.

Cause of death: Washington. Lombardo had a bipartisan record with a Democratic legislature. Ford spent the campaign tying him to Trump and blaming him for the cost of groceries, gas, housing and healthcare. The Culinary Union, which claims up to 60,000 members, ran a major turnout operation for Ford (WGCU, from NPR).

Lesson: Like Susan Collins in Maine, Lombardo shows that a good local record cannot outrun a bad national one. Democrats also had a year-round turnout machine in the Culinary Union. Republicans need their own, and young voters are where to build it.

Florida: a hold that should worry us

Rep. Byron Donalds beat former Rep. David Jolly 50.0% to 48.7% to succeed Gov. Ron DeSantis, becoming Florida's first Black governor (MultiState). The final polling average had him ahead by 4 points.

Florida has been the Republican Party's strongest large state. Holding it by 1.3 points is a warning, not a victory. Why the race tightened deserves a study of its own.

What the governors' races tell us

  1. Primaries keep handing us the wrong nominees. Self-funders, first-time candidates and nominees chosen for their Trump branding lost in Georgia, Iowa and Ohio.

  2. The voucher fight cost us twice. In Texas and Iowa, Democrats ran on public schools against Republicans who defended private-school programs.

  3. Conduct matters. Ohio voters punished an attack that crossed the line, and young voters are watching how the party behaves.

  4. Democrats out-organized us. From the Culinary Union in Nevada to record turnout in Texas, they had year-round operations. That is the gap HSREPS exists to close.

Race-by-race autopsies: the House

Republicans lost the House by a landslide: CBS estimates Democrats will hold between 251 and 268 seats once counting ends. At least 15 Republican incumbents lost, and Democrats won seats that Republican legislatures had redrawn in our favor (CBS News).

  • Pennsylvania: Brian Fitzpatrick, Ryan Mackenzie, Rob Bresnahan Jr., Scott Perry

  • Iowa: Mariannette Miller-Meeks, Zach Nunn

  • Wisconsin: Brian Steil, Derrick Van Orden

  • Ohio: Max Miller, Mike Carey

  • New Jersey: Tom Kean

  • Missouri: Ann Wagner

  • Colorado: Gabe Evans

  • Indiana: Victoria Spartz

  • Virginia: Jen Kiggans

Democrats also flipped open Republican seats in Iowa, Kentucky's 6th, Nebraska's 2nd and North Carolina's 11th.

Cause of death: the national tide reached every kind of district

The losses cut across every type of Republican member. Brian Fitzpatrick had one of the most independent voting records in the House and lost anyway. Scott Perry, a former Freedom Caucus chairman, lost too. Suburban seats in New Jersey and Missouri fell alongside rural seats in Iowa and Wisconsin. When moderates and hardliners lose on the same night, the cause is not any one member's voting record. It is the national environment described in the exit polls.

Redistricting did not save us

Republicans redrew maps in several states before 2026. They did not hold. Democrats won Texas's 15th and 23rd districts despite new lines, and at least three redrawn Florida seats went Democratic (CBS News; Northeastern). A map drawn for a 2024 electorate cannot protect a party that loses its voters by 2026.

Money did not save us either

Two of the ten most expensive House races in the country were Republican seats we lost: Colorado's 8th, where Rep. Gabe Evans lost in a $51.9 million race, and Wisconsin's 3rd, where Rep. Derrick Van Orden lost in a $44.8 million race (Dave Manuel money tracker).

What the House tells us

The House is where young voters bite hardest, because House seats are won and lost by a few thousand votes. A party that loses voters under 30 by 48 points does not need a bad candidate to lose a swing district. Mapmaking and money are short-term fixes. The long-term fix is winning the next generation of voters before they reach the ballot box.

Organization and outreach: the party's youth record

The Republican youth problem is organizational before it is ideological. The party has no official youth pipeline, and the youth structures it did have have been allowed to fall apart.

The RNC's own youth council walked out

In December 2023, five of the 16 members of the RNC's Youth Advisory Council resigned. In a letter to the chair, they cited a "lack of organization, lack of tangible goals and benchmarks, and general lack of vision." They wrote that they refused to be used as "shiny objects" in RNC fundraising (Fox News). The RNC said at the time that the council was working on messaging and its "Bank Your Vote" effort. The warning went unheeded. The Youth Advisory Board was later dissolved under Chairman Michael Whatley (Wikipedia).

The College Republicans broke into pieces

The College Republican National Committee was an official RNC auxiliary from 1972 until 2002, when campaign finance law led it to reorganize as an independent group. Since 2019 it has been hit by financial and governance scandals and lost its official RNC ties. Only three state federations remain chartered with it (Wikipedia).

Students did not stop organizing. Out of the wreckage came the National Federation of College Republicans, founded in 2022, which now counts more than 25 state federations and describes itself as the largest and most active College Republican organization in the country (NFCR). The NFCR is now officially part of the Young Republicans, giving conservative students a real path from campus into the party's young professional network. It is the college organization the party should build on. A rival group, College Republicans of America, has also sought RNC recognition (College Republicans of America); we found no record of an RNC answer to either group.

High schools were left to whoever showed up

At the high school level there is no RNC-recognized organization at all. Outreach has been left to independent groups, and in Texas to a governor's mandate that backfired. HSREPS chapters, Turning Point's Club America chapters and other conservative clubs all compete for the same students, the same donors and the same school approvals, with no coordination and no path from one to the next.

HSREPS's own review

HSREPS will hold itself to the same standard. Our review of our own campaign organization, outreach and digital work will report:

  • Active chapters by state, and chapters founded or lost during 2026

  • Students reached through chapter events, door-knocking and phone banks

  • Voter registration among members who turned 18 before Election Day

  • Reach and engagement on each digital platform, and which content moved students to act

  • Where chapters asked for support and did not get it

These figures are being compiled from chapter reports and will be published when complete.

Chapter leader and volunteer experiences

The students who knocked on doors and carried our message into their schools saw this election up close. HSREPS is gathering their accounts from every chapter, and asking each chapter leader and volunteer:

  1. What issues did students at your school care about most this year?

  2. What did classmates say when you talked to them about Republican candidates?

  3. Which outreach worked best: in person, at school events, or online? On which platforms?

  4. Did your chapter face obstacles from your school, your community, or other organizations?

  5. What support from HSREPS, or from the party, would have made the biggest difference?

  6. What should Republicans do differently to win your generation?

Responses will be summarized by theme, with quotes used only with permission. Students' names will not be published without their consent and, for those under 18, a parent's.

Findings and recommendations: two youth movements

Democrats did not win young voters by 48 points by accident. They built a youth movement inside their party, with a seat at the table and a path from high school to the national committee. Republicans have conservative students in every state and no structure to hold them.

The Democratic pipeline

  • High school. High School Democrats of America calls itself the official high school branch of the Democratic National Committee. In 2019 the DNC amended its charter to give HSDA two seats on the committee, which HSDA describes as voting seats. In 2025 the DNC added a seat for HSDA's national chair on its Executive Committee (HSDA; Insider NJ).

  • College. The College Democrats of America is recognized as the DNC's official college outreach arm and reports more than 100,000 members (Wikipedia).

  • Young adults. The Young Democrats of America covers Democrats aged 14 to 35, and its president, national committeeman and national committeewoman sit on the DNC (Wikipedia).

  • The pipeline. HSDA began as the Young Democrats' high school caucus and still partners with both the College Democrats and the Young Democrats. A student can join at 14 and move up through the same party family until they are running for office.

The Republican landscape

  • Official high school organization. Democrats have HSDA, the DNC's recognized high school branch. Republicans have none recognized by the RNC.

  • Seats on the national committee. On the DNC, HSDA holds two seats plus an Executive Committee seat, and the Young Democrats hold three. On the RNC, youth groups hold none; all 168 members are state chairs, committeemen and committeewomen.

  • College organization. Democrats have the College Democrats, the DNC's official college outreach arm. Republicans have the NFCR, the largest College Republican organization and now part of the Young Republicans, but it is not recognized by the RNC.

  • Path from high school to adulthood. Democrats run from HSDA to the College Democrats to the Young Democrats, as partner organizations. Republicans run from the NFCR to the Young Republicans, with no path from high school into either.

  • Young voters in 2026. Democrats won 73%; Republicans won 25%.

Sources: HSDA, Wikipedia: Republican National Committee, Wikipedia: College Republican National Committee, NBC News exit poll.

The conservative youth movement is not small. Turning Point USA and its Club America chapters, Young America's Foundation, the College Republicans, now led by the NFCR, the Young Republicans and HSREPS all organize young conservatives. That energy is real. But it is scattered across groups that compete for the same students and the same donors, with no seat at the party's table and no path from one to the next. Democrats built an army. We have a crowd.

[INSERT IMAGE: Youth_Pipeline_Diagram.png]

Every Democratic youth group leads into the next and ends at a seat on the DNC. On the Republican side, the NFCR and the Young Republicans are the start of a pipeline. Nothing connects high school to it, and nothing connects any of it to the RNC.

What the autopsy found

  1. Republicans lost young voters by 48 points, two years after winning a majority of young men.

  2. Candidate selection decided our worst losses. Texas, South Carolina, North Carolina, Georgia, Iowa and Ohio were all lost by nominees chosen for loyalty, name, money or party service rather than strength in November.

  3. The party ran on Washington's agenda, not the voters'. Tariffs, the war in Iran, data centers and vouchers cost us in red and blue states alike.

  4. Money and maps did not save us. We lost nine of the ten most expensive Senate races and House seats drawn in our favor.

  5. Democrats out-organized us, starting in high school. Their youth movement is part of their party. Ours is outside it.

What HSREPS asks of the Republican National Committee

  1. Recognize HSREPS as the RNC's official high school organization, as the DNC recognized High School Democrats of America in 2019.

  2. Give the next generation a vote. Amend the RNC rules to seat representatives of recognized youth organizations on the committee, starting with HSREPS's national chair.

  3. Fund youth outreach year-round. A dedicated budget for chapters, training and digital outreach, not money that appears in October of an election year.

  4. Build the pipeline. The NFCR and the Young Republicans have already joined forces. Recognize them alongside HSREPS, and close the last gap: a formal path from HSREPS chapters into the NFCR, so a student who joins at 14 has a place in the party at every age.

  5. Keep it student-led. Texas showed what happens when politics is ordered into schools from the top down. Fund the chapters students start themselves.

  6. Let young voters weigh in on candidates. Give recognized youth organizations a role in candidate recruitment, so the party hears what our generation wants before the primaries, not after the losses.

What HSREPS commits to

Our strategy rests on the two priorities we set after the election: meeting students where they already are, on campus and online, and growing our chapters. We will publish the results of our own review, share our chapter leaders' accounts, and measure ourselves by the same standard we are asking of the party.

The Republican Party lost young voters in 2026 because it treated them as an afterthought. It can win them back by treating them as the future of the movement. The students who carry conservative ideas into their classrooms every day are ready. The party needs to meet them there.

Connor McFarland

Chair; High School Republican National Federation

More from Connor

William Birch

National Secretary; High School Republican National Federation

More from William

Get Conservateen in your inbox

The day’s essential reporting and opinion. Free.

An Autopsy of the 2026 Midterm Election | Conservateen